Ellen MacArthur Foundation | Case Study: Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies – Closing the Nutrient Loop
Read original case study: https://www.ellenmacarthurfoundation.org/case-studies/closing-the-nutrient-loop
Overview
The Need – the current linear approach to agriculture removes important nutrients from the soil, passes them through a value chain and discards them in a way that can lead to unproductive soil and negative environmental impacts. There are finite reserves of many key resources and in some cases, such as phosphorus, there is no synthetic alternative.
The Solution – Ostara has developed technology that can be incorporated into treatment plants allowing phosphorus and other nutrients to be recovered from industrial and municipal wastewater streams. The product can then be marketed, distributed and sold to blenders, growers and farmers as a pure and effective fertiliser, produced from resources that would otherwise be wasted.
What makes it particularly smart – the process reduces the build up of phosphorus and other nutrients, called struvite, on pumps and pipework. This addresses a costly operational issue, common in treatment plants, using biological phosphorus removal. The end product called ‘Crystal Green’ is not water soluble; it releases nutrients to plants in response to growing roots, which means there is a significant reduction in leaching and runoff from crops, as the plants are more efficiently nourished.
The Result – wastewater plants have an additional revenue stream, increased efficiency and lower operational costs; nutrient loading to waterways is reduced; fertiliser efficiency is improved for farmers and there is a reduced carbon intensity.
Healthy soils are the foundation of the bio-economy
A balanced supply of nutrients is essential for healthy plant growth. In the absence of human activities, natural processes such as biodegradation as well as symbiotic relationships with other species in the local ecosystem provide sufficient nutrition for the plant life cycle, albeit in an environment of healthy competition.
Human agricultural activities affect this natural nutrient balance. When crops are harvested nutrients are removed from the soil, as they are contained in the grains, vegetables, fruits, fodder, timber and other useful biomass that is taken away. All of these are important materials for feeding people and supporting the economy, but the process removes essential elements required for future generations of plant growth.
In the past, less mechanised, more local forms of agriculture returned nutrients in the form of agricultural by-products, the spreading of human and animal waste and intercropping. As farming methods have become more industrialised and mono-cultured, the effect has been to increase yields, leading to improved profit margins, lower food costs and a reduction in hunger. However sustaining yields means soil health and fertility is now provided by artificial chemicals rather than natural means. These chemical alternatives can be expensive, relying on resources that are increasingly hard to recover and involve carbon intensive production processes.Furthermore, current chemical fertiliser utilisation is quite ineffective. A report released in 2015 estimated that only 5% of the fertilisers applied, contribute to parts of plants that we eat.
Meanwhile at the other end…
At the other end of the chain is the wastewater treatment plant. Nutrients, by now dissolved in municipal and industrial wastewater, are captured in expensive mechanical, biological and chemical processes. This ensures that water is safe to be discharged into the wider water system, according to local environmental regulations.
Spurred on by increasingly stringent regulation, Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies, a Vancouver-based company, has taken a more systemic approach to managing nutrient flows. The result is an innovative wastewater add-on process and a pure fertiliser product that creates revenue for the business.
The location of phosphorus determines whether it is a liability or an asset. When deposited as the mineral phosphate struvite on pipe and pump work in treatment plants, or if discharged in elevated concentrations to freshwater sources, phosphorus can be both economically and environmentally costly. However in the form of a fertiliser product contributing to high yields and healthy plants, phosphorus can be an attractive revenue stream.
Recognising this dichotomy, Ostara developed a nutrient recovery approach called the ‘Pearl® Nutrient Recovery Process’, easily integrated into biological-based wastewater plants, reducing problematic phosphorus and turning it into a highly effective plant fertiliser called ‘Crystal Green®’.
How it works
Ostara’s solution is a two-stage process that can be applied to a particular configuration of sewage treatment (known as Enhanced Biological Phosphorus Removal), a treatment method in which biological processes are selectively enriched with specific phosphate-absorbing bacteria. Having accumulated large quantities of polyphosphate within their cells, the bacteria re-release the phosphorus into a soluble form and then placed in an anaerobic digester. The result is a concentrated, phosphorus-rich stream that is fed through Ostara’s ‘Pearl Process’, where phosphate crystallises into pure fertiliser granules.
The process is complemented by a second installation (called WASSTRIP) that diverts wastewater upstream of the anaerobic digester, significantly reducing struvite build up in critical plant components as well as maximising phosphate recovery by the Pearl process. In the further material section at the end of this article, a video link provides a visual explanation of how these two processes are integrated into a typical treatment works.
The technology can be applied in a number of reactor sizes according to the population served, ranging from 50,000 to 1 million populations. Pearl and WASSTRIP can either be retrofitted into existing facilities or incorporated into the design of brand new plants.
Win-win-win
Ostara’s nutrient recovery system provides financial benefits to farmers, utility companies and shareholders, while at the same time satisfying regulators and conservation groups. Ostara also avoids negative impacts to the local aquatic environment, contributes to positive urban-rural connectivity and reduces carbon intensity associated with agriculture.
Financially, farmers are better off because they do not need to use so much fertiliser. Crystal Green is known as a ‘continuous release, Root-Activated™’ product. This means that instead of acting through water solubility, the fertiliser granules hold back until signalled via a chemical message from the plant root to release nutrients into the soil. Unlike conventional fertiliser application where up to 75% can be washed away, Crystal Green fertiliser is transferred much more effectively to the plant, avoiding excessive nutrients which could cause eutrophication in nearby bodies of water, whilst also remaining available to the plants for a much longer proportion of the growing season. Utility companies are financially better off, as an additional revenue stream has been created through fertiliser sales. Besides these extra profits, their operational costs are also lowered as less chemicals are needed to manage struvite deposits, and there is a 10-20% reduction in leftover sludge requiring disposal.
In global terms, greenhouse gas emissions are reduced as each tonne of Crystal Green eliminates 10 tonnes of CO2e compared to equivalent standard fertilisers. If scaled up, this could be an important contribution to reducing the carbon intensity of the agricultural sector, which is estimated to be responsible for 17% of emissions.
The basic template for an urban sewage system has remained unchanged since the 1870s, when the world’s first underground network was installed in London. While Bazalgette’s system was very effective at cleaning up the ‘Great Stink’, its design was extremely ‘linear’ in that it took nutrients from where they are useful (farms), discarding them to a place where they are problematic (waterways). Technology like Ostara’s should be the next evolution of Bazalgette’s ideas, ensuring that the next generation of more ‘circular’ sewage systems not only protect public health but also close nutrient loops back to farmland.
Company info
- Founded in 2005
- 35 full time staff
- HQ Vancouver, Canada
- 15 commercial installations worldwide
Further material: Video – Ostara Nutrient Recovery Solutions; Urban bio-cycle economy report

Ostara Raises up to US$16.5 Million with Existing Investors to Support Production Scale-up and Accelerate Global Growth

Ostara Enters into Long-Term Granulation Tolling Agreement in Response to Increasing Crystal Green Sales Demand

Shafdan Wastewater Treatment Plant will be the first in the region to install an Ostara Nutrient Recovery Facility

City of St. Cloud to Install Ostara’s Nutrient Recovery Technology as Key Part of the City’s Nutrient Recovery and Reuse Project

Ostara to Deliver City of Atlanta Nutrient Recovery Facility Through Unique Alternative Finance Model

Ellen MacArthur Foundation | Case Study: Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies – Closing the Nutrient Loop

Treatment Plant Operator | Water Environment Federation Presents Awards for Operational and Design Excellence

The MWRD of Greater Chicago’s Nutrient Recovery Facility earns Top Honor from Water Environment Federation

Executive Voice Publishing | The Best of Canada Report: Honoring Canada’s 150 year Legacy of Commercial Success (as seen in Bloomberg and The Wall Street Journal)

SDTC SUCCESS STORY | Partnering for real results. Meeting environmental goals. Moving cleantech to market.

Black & Veatch | World’s largest nutrient recovery facility produces valuable, environmentally friendly fertilizer

AQUA STRATEGY | A growth opportunity – how recovery of phosphorus from wastewater is bringing success for Ostara

ESEM | Wastewater converted to ecofriendly fertilizer with the help of dewatering, classifying screeners

VANCOUVER SUN | Vancouver’s Ostara aims to harvest from municipal waste rather than mining phosphorus

WATER BRIEFING | Dutch Waterboard opens Europe’s first nutrient recovery facility at Amersfoort WwTW

DUTCH WATER SECTOR | Next-step sludge treatment integrates three advanced technologies at wwtp Amersfoort, the Netherlands

SUSTAINABLE BRANDS | Chemical Plant, Nutrient Recovery Facility Bring Circular Economy One Step Closer

Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago and Ostara Open World’s Largest Nutrient Recovery Facility to Help Recover Phosphorus and Protect Mississippi River Basin

Dutch Waterboard Vallei en Veluwe and Ostara to produce high-value fertiliser, Crystal Green® at Amersfoort WWTP

Ostara is named in the 2015 Global Cleantech 100: Recognized as a Pioneer in Shaping the Future of Resource Recovery

ACWA Services partners with Ostara to offer Phosphorus Recovery Revenue Stream for UK Water Companies

Ostara is Named in the 2014 Global Cleantech 100 for 6th Straight year: Recognized as Market Leader in Waste to Wealth Technology

Ostara Sees Improved Dewaterability and Reduced Biosolids Production with Waste-activated Sludge Stripping Technology

Madison Metropolitan Sewerage District and Ostara Help Dane County Lead the Way in Reducing Nutrient Pollution

What operational benefits and political motivation persuade utilities to install nutrient recovery systems?

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies wins Technology Green 15™ Award at the 2013 Deloitte Technology Fast 50™ Awards

Come, friendly bombs, don’t fall on Slough. It’s doing good for humans now: Berkshire town to launch £2m nutrient-recovery reactor

BBC World News Horizons explores why human waste is one of biggest public health issues facing world today

Ostara Named to 2013 Global Cleantech 100 List: Recognized as Market Leader in Technology with World-Changing Impact

Ostara Named to 2013 Global Cleantech 100 List: Recognized as Market Leader in Technology with World-Changing Impact

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Chicago’s Metropolitan Water Reclamation District Discuss Nutrient Recovery’s Crucial Role in Combatting Water Pollution

Black & Veatch and Ostara to Design-Build New Nutrient Recovery System for World’s Largest Water Reclamation Plant

Black & Veatch and Ostara to Design-Build New Nutrient Recovery System for World’s Largest Water Reclamation Plant

Clean Water Services and Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Open World’s Largest Municipal Nutrient Recovery Facility

Hampton Roads Sanitation District and Ostara Win National Council of Public-Private Partnerships Award

Madison Metropolitan Sewerage District and Ostara Partner to Install Commercial Nutrient Recovery Facility

Virginia Wastewater Treatment Plant First In Chesapeake Bay Watershed to Recover Nutrients and Transform Them into “Green” Commercial Fertilizer

Media Alert: Unveiling of New Nutrient Recovery Facility That Will Protect Chesapeake Bay, with Keynote Speaker Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.

World’s Only Slow Release, Renewable Fertiliser Begins Commercial Production – Crystal Green® Proven Effective for Turf, Nursery, Specialty Markets

HRSD Treatment Plant to Build Full-Scale Nutrient Recycling Facility Nutrients will be Recycled into ‘Green’ Commercial Fertilizer

Severn Trent First in Europe to Recycle Nutrients into “Environmentally Friendly” Commercial Fertiliser

VantagePoint Venture Partner’s Portfolio Companies Take Top Rankings in Guardian’s Global CleanTech 100

Oregon Wastewater Treatment Plant First in the U.S. to Recycle Nutrients Into ‘Green’ Commercial Fertilizer

SFPUC and Ostara Demonstrate Innovative Technology That Recycles Harmful Sewage Byproduct to Environmentally-safe Fertilizer

SFPUC and Ostara Demonstrate Innovative Technology That Recycles Harmful Sewage Byproduct to Environmentally-Safe Fertilizer

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Raises U.S. $10.5 Million to Accelerate Commercialization of CleanTech Water Treatment Process

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc.: Oregon Wastewater Treatment Plant Is the First in U.S. to Recycle Nutrients Into “Green” Commercial Fertilizer

Edmonton Reveals World’s First Industrial Scale Sewage Treatment Facility to Recycle Nutrients Into Environmentally-Safe Commercial Fertilizer

Clean Water Services’ wastewater treatment facility conducts trials of new environmentally-friendly technology from Canadian company
© 2019 Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc. Home | Technology | Nutrients | Contact Us