WE&T | Resource to recovery: Nutrient recovery and the evolution of utilities of the future
Nutrient recovery and the evolution of utilities of the future
jULY 2016 â By Phillip Abrary –
Nutrient pollution is one of the greatest challenges facing communities today. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimates that more than 15,000 bodies of water have nutrient impairments, including highly used recreational areas such as Chesapeake Bay and Lake Erie. Responsible for toxic algae blooms, an excess of nutrients in waterways can create conditions that destroy aquatic life and severely limit recreational enjoyment, accounting for millions of dollars in lost tourism revenue. As a result, as part of the Clean Water Act, EPA is implementing more stringent regulations in an effort to battle nutrient pollution, and municipalities are facing greater challenges in meeting these newly enforced limits.
While compliance historically has been a significant driver of innovation, there now is also a strong interest within the water sector to advance sustainability and corporate responsibility. In fact, many wastewater treatment plants now define themselves as water resource recovery facilities (WRRFs), where water, energy, and nutrients are recovered and recycled for beneficial reuse.
Raising the bar for nutrient recovery
When phosphorus limits were first imposed, wastewater facilities commonly met regulatory limits by removing phosphorus using chemicals. The facilities precipitated nutrients with iron or aluminum salts and removed the precipitate via biosolids. This was an expensive process that generated excess biosolids and required the purchase of metals salts and the disposal of the metal phosphate sludge.
Enhanced biological phosphorus removal (EBPR) emerged as an alternative across North America and Europe in the 1990s â EBPR has been available since the 1960s but wasnât widely used. Unlike chemical phosphorus removal, EBPR is considered a low-cost, environmentally friendly solution that relies on special bacteria â phosphate accumulating organisms (PAOs) â to remove phosphorus. Issues arise, however, during anaerobic digestion, where PAOs release phosphorus and other nutrients. The released phosphorus can react with ammonia released in digesters and magnesium to form a scale, struvite. Struvite can cause severe buildup in pipes, process equipment, and digesters. To prevent this buildup, facilities again needed to resort to chemical phosphorus removal using metal salts, essentially turning the phosphorus back into a solid waste to be disposed of.
In the 2000s, todayâs prevailing technology emerged: Controlled crystallization of phosphorus into a granular highly pure high-value fertilizer. Researchers at the University of British Columbia understood that struvite had potential to be a valuable fertilizer when they developed the technology to extract the dissolved phosphorus, ammonia, and magnesium. The technology carefully forms and grows crystals having the purity and size characteristics that would allow it to be blended and used as a commercial fertilizer. The technology was commercialized under the name Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies when the company was formed in 2005. In 2007, Ostaraâs technology had been scaled up by a factor of 100, from laboratory to commercial scale. Again, 2 years later, Clean Water Services in Portland, Ore., launched the first commercial installation of the technology. Today, 12 facilities operate commercially worldwide, with more coming online this year.
In May, the worldâs largest nutrient recovery facility launched in partnership with the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago at the Stickney Water Reclamation Plant in Cicero, Ill. The facility has the production capacity of up to 30 tons/d of high-value fertilizer, sold as Crystal Green.
Indicative of progress
The implementation of this technology at the Stickney facility is an example of how progressive technology and leadership can transform a wastewater treatment plant into a water resource recovery facility. This facility represents a significant shift in the wastewater sector to standardize recovery for reuse and reflects the evolution nutrient recovery has undergone.
Although market adoption was dependent on several critical factors, initial successes can be attributed to strategic partnerships with progressive utilities. This model has several elements that contribute to its success:
treating clients as long-term partners,
running extensive pilot tests prior to installation,
gathering real-time commercial data to illustrate technical benefits,
continuing to provide continual operational support once a facility is running, and
providing a guaranteed buyer for the product.
The goal always should be to provide affordable business models to make new technology adoption financially attractive, as well as to quicken the payback to utilities.
Turning wastes into reusable products
Beyond the challenges of scaling-up a technology and ensuring that it meets the treatment objectives required by a wastewater treatment utility, there is an element of alignment that is critical to building a strong partnership that gives both parties a true winâwin.
In designing the business model for nutrient recovery â and unlike energy and water resource recovery â it became apparent that wastewater utilities were neither properly equipped nor particularly interested in being in the commercial fertilizer business. To address this issue and achieve optimal and consistent value for the product, Ostara established a division focused exclusively on the development and maintenance of a market for the produced fertilizer. By consolidating production volumes and ensuring consistent quality, a branded product could be created. So, as part of every system sale, customers are provided with a long-term off-take for all of the produced fertilizer that, in turn, provides economic certainty and aligns both partiesâ interests toward achieving maximum nutrient recovery.
The technology provider benefits directly from the continued successful operation of a facility while the wastewater utility similarly gains from operating the system in an optimal manner. Through this alignment both parties have a vested interest in maintaining a strong and cooperative partnership.
Innovation adoption can be challenging in the risk-averse water sector. However, recovery for reuse has shown benefits in enhanced operational efficiency, reliably meeting compliance targets, reducing operational costs (from maintenance and chemicals), and creating value from nutrients that would otherwise be lost. Those who have taken the perceived risk to date can attest to nutrient recovery as a winâwin both economically and environmentally.
Today, water utilities represent more than âtreatment facilities.â They are energy providers and resource recovery centers. They carry significant pressures to innovate while also ensuring safe, resilient systems that protect both public health and the environment.
As WRRFs continue to face increasingly rigorous phosphorus limits, nutrient recovery stands as an example as to whatâs possible in reshaping the utility landscape.

Ostara and Oakley Sign Letter of Intent for Purchase of Oakleyâs St. Louis Granulation Facility and Long-term Terminal Services

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc. & City of Atlanta Announce Official Launch of Nutrient Recovery Facility

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc. and ICL Specialty Fertilizers Expand Distribution of Recycled Nutrients into New Territories

Ostara Provides Corporate Update: Additional Growth Capital from Equity Funding and New Credit Facility; New Board Director, Monty Bayer

Reimagining the Future of Phosphates at Symphos 2019; Phosphorus Recovery, Sustainability and the Circular Economy.

Ostara Raises up to US$16.5 Million with Existing Investors to Support Production Scale-up and Accelerate Global Growth

Ostara Enters into Long-Term Granulation Tolling Agreement in Response to Increasing Crystal Green Sales Demand

Shafdan Wastewater Treatment Plant will be the first in the region to install an Ostara Nutrient Recovery Facility

City of St. Cloud to Install Ostaraâs Nutrient Recovery Technology as Key Part of the Cityâs Nutrient Recovery and Reuse Project

Ostara to Deliver City of Atlanta Nutrient Recovery Facility Through Unique Alternative Finance Model

Ellen MacArthur Foundation | Case Study: Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies – Closing the Nutrient Loop

Treatment Plant Operator | Water Environment Federation Presents Awards for Operational and Design Excellence

The MWRD of Greater Chicagoâs Nutrient Recovery Facility earns Top Honor from Water Environment Federation

Executive Voice Publishing | The Best of Canada Report: Honoring Canada’s 150 year Legacy of Commercial Success (as seen in Bloomberg and The Wall Street Journal)

SDTC SUCCESS STORY | Partnering for real results. Meeting environmental goals. Moving cleantech to market.

Black & Veatch | Worldâs largest nutrient recovery facility produces valuable, environmentally friendly fertilizer

AQUA STRATEGY | A growth opportunity – how recovery of phosphorus from wastewater is bringing success for Ostara

ESEM | Wastewater converted to ecofriendly fertilizer with the help of dewatering, classifying screeners

WATER ONLINE | Measuring The Impact Of Phosphorus Recovery â From The Midwest To The Gulf Of Mexico

VANCOUVER SUN | Vancouver’s Ostara aims to harvest from municipal waste rather than mining phosphorus

WATER BRIEFING | Dutch Waterboard opens Europeâs first nutrient recovery facility at Amersfoort WwTW

DUTCH WATER SECTOR | Next-step sludge treatment integrates three advanced technologies at wwtp Amersfoort, the Netherlands

SUSTAINABLE BRANDS | Chemical Plant, Nutrient Recovery Facility Bring Circular Economy One Step Closer

Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago and Ostara Open Worldâs Largest Nutrient Recovery Facility to Help Recover Phosphorus and Protect Mississippi River Basin

Dutch Waterboard Vallei en Veluwe and Ostara to produce high-value fertiliser, Crystal GreenÂŽ at Amersfoort WWTP

Ostara is named in the 2015 Global Cleantech 100: Recognized as a Pioneer in Shaping the Future of Resource Recovery

ACWA Services partners with Ostara to offer Phosphorus Recovery Revenue Stream for UK Water Companies

Ostara is Named in the 2014 Global Cleantech 100 for 6th Straight year: Recognized as Market Leader in Waste to Wealth Technology

Ostara Sees Improved Dewaterability and Reduced Biosolids Production with Waste-activated Sludge Stripping Technology

Madison Metropolitan Sewerage District and Ostara Help Dane County Lead the Way in Reducing Nutrient Pollution

What operational benefits and political motivation persuade utilities to install nutrient recovery systems?

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies wins Technology Green 15⢠Award at the 2013 Deloitte Technology Fast 50⢠Awards

Come, friendly bombs, don’t fall on Slough. It’s doing good for humans now: Berkshire town to launch ÂŁ2m nutrient-recovery reactor

BBC World News Horizons explores why human waste is one of biggest public health issues facing world today

Ostara Named to 2013 Global Cleantech 100 List: Recognized as Market Leader in Technology with World-Changing Impact

Ostara Named to 2013 Global Cleantech 100 List: Recognized as Market Leader in Technology with World-Changing Impact

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Chicagoâs Metropolitan Water Reclamation District Discuss Nutrient Recoveryâs Crucial Role in Combatting Water Pollution

Black & Veatch and Ostara to Design-Build New Nutrient Recovery System for Worldâs Largest Water Reclamation Plant

Black & Veatch and Ostara to Design-Build New Nutrient Recovery System for World’s Largest Water Reclamation Plant

Clean Water Services and Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Open World’s Largest Municipal Nutrient Recovery Facility

Hampton Roads Sanitation District and Ostara Win National Council of Public-Private Partnerships Award

Madison Metropolitan Sewerage District and Ostara Partner to Install Commercial Nutrient Recovery Facility

Virginia Wastewater Treatment Plant First In Chesapeake Bay Watershed to Recover Nutrients and Transform Them into âGreenâ Commercial Fertilizer

Media Alert: Unveiling of New Nutrient Recovery Facility That Will Protect Chesapeake Bay, with Keynote Speaker Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.

World’s Only Slow Release, Renewable Fertiliser Begins Commercial Production – Crystal GreenÂŽ Proven Effective for Turf, Nursery, Specialty Markets

HRSD Treatment Plant to Build Full-Scale Nutrient Recycling Facility Nutrients will be Recycled into âGreenâ Commercial Fertilizer

Severn Trent First in Europe to Recycle Nutrients into âEnvironmentally Friendlyâ Commercial Fertiliser

VantagePoint Venture Partnerâs Portfolio Companies Take Top Rankings in Guardianâs Global CleanTech 100

Oregon Wastewater Treatment Plant First in the U.S. to Recycle Nutrients Into ‘Green’ Commercial Fertilizer

SFPUC and Ostara Demonstrate Innovative Technology That Recycles Harmful Sewage Byproduct to Environmentally-safe Fertilizer

SFPUC and Ostara Demonstrate Innovative Technology That Recycles Harmful Sewage Byproduct to Environmentally-Safe Fertilizer

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Raises U.S. $10.5 Million to Accelerate Commercialization of CleanTech Water Treatment Process

Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc.: Oregon Wastewater Treatment Plant Is the First in U.S. to Recycle Nutrients Into “Green” Commercial Fertilizer

Edmonton Reveals World’s First Industrial Scale Sewage Treatment Facility to Recycle Nutrients Into Environmentally-Safe Commercial Fertilizer

Clean Water Servicesâ wastewater treatment facility conducts trials of new environmentally-friendly technology from Canadian company
Â
Š 2020 Ostara Nutrient Recovery Technologies Inc. Home | Technology | Nutrients | Contact UsÂ
Â